| IT
could be the "lost city" in some theme park. In the jungle-like
overgrowth a visitor can see only 10 or 20 feet. Every 100 feet
or so stone ruins loom. But there are no guides and admission is
free: This is the Farm Colony, Staten Island's early-20th-century
charitable complex.
A 1988 project by the Department
of General Services to sell the site for housing has been set back
and this unusual group of buildings seems headed more towards archeology
than to restoration.
What became the New York City Farm Colony was established in 1829
as the Richmond County Poor Farm, where the indigent received room
and board in exchange for farm work. Dr. Shirley Zavin, an architectural
historian at the Landmarks Preservation Commission, said the first
building went up in the 1830's on the west side of Brielle Avenue
in the middle of the island.

In 1893, the Poor Farm was
renamed the Farm Colony, but Staten Island was merged into New York
City in 1898 and the city centralized the planning and analysis
for such efforts. A 1902 report said that the Farm Colony, at the
time with a population of about 200, could produce vegetables to
support 3,000 people.
A new building began at this
time and by 1915 there were seven dormitories and staff buildings
in a campus-like setting with irregular rows and walkways. Four
successive architectural firms designed buildings in this group
but all followed the general styling of the original designers,
Renwick, Aspinwall & Owen: walls of local dark rubble stone
with occasional red brick infill and gambrel roofs.
By the 1910's 63 acres of the
104-acre site were under cultivation, producing fruit, vegetables,
swine and chickens. The 824 residents were supervised by 150 employees.
In 1912, they produced $22,887 in food -- but over half the population
was over 50 years old, one-quarter over 70. By the 1920's the policy
had shifted from attempts at self-support and in 1932 the complex
was described as "a haven for old people" with 1,428 residents.
Around this time Charles B.
Meyers built four H-shaped Georgian-style dormitories with brick
facades. By the 50's, the complex had become a geriatric hospital
and home. It closed in 1975 and in 1985 the landmarks agency designated
it and the Seaview Hospital complex, on the other side of Brielle
Avenue, a historic district.
|
|
In
1988, the Department of General Services issued a Request for Expression
of Interest to developers for the Farm Colony site. Calling it the
Woodlands, the department sought preliminary responses from developers
who would buy the site for new housing units -- 150, 344, 558 or
970. The 150-unit plan would have been straight rehabilitation of
the existing buildings, the others would have involved new construction,
too. Lisa Ryan, a spokeswoman for the department, said 10 complete
responses were received, most favoring the 344-unit or 558-unit
options. No one was interested in straight rehabilitation.

But while the department was
evaluating the responses, new city regulations required an entirely
new environmental impact statement at a cost of up to $100,000.
MRS. RYAN said the department
has not yet come back to the project and it is not clear when it
will start moving again, if ever.
Today a visitor going in through
the open gate will find an allee of mature trees quickly developing
into a tangled jungle. In the shadowy growth, a derelict building
will be seen. Some structures are largely sealed up, most are wide
open. Everywhere the jungle presses up close to the windows, making
them into green filters.
One building recently has been
gutted by fire, with huge charred timbers leaning down, and metal
doors swinging open into nothingness.
Besides occasional vandalism,
the only fresh evidence of human presence is spray-painted marking
on the tree-choked roads locating fire hydrants that are completely
invisible in the undergrowth. The woodlands title for the development
may prove to be particularly apt; the jungle has now begun to invade
the interiors of the buildings with vines and seedlings.
|